Bids came in over the July 4 weekend at 217 Hommocks Road, a waterfront house built in 1898 and known as Villa Cheri, and they ended with an accepted offer. Larchmont Loop reported that multiple offers brought the sale to 8.6% above the list price. The final price was $19 million, nearly double the previous Larchmont record. In November, lohud reported the sale as a record for the village, and noted the 1.38 acres, private dock, pool, cabana, gazebo and private beach.
Both reports are accurate. "8.6% over asking" is also accurate, and it depends entirely on which asking price you measure against. This house had four of them in just under seven years. For anyone comparing Larchmont with other Sound Shore towns this winter, the percentage over asking says more about where a seller set the price than about how much buyers wanted the house. The fall 2026 sales show the same pattern in a lower price range too.
Four asking prices for one house
The full listing history for 217 Hommocks Road is public on the property's Compass record. The house was listed at $7.9 million in October 2019 and sold for $7,215,000 on October 30, 2020. After the multiyear renovation Larchmont Loop described, it came back on the market at $23 million on October 20, 2025. That listing was withdrawn on February 2, 2026.
On March 13, 2026, the house was relisted at $19.5 million. On June 9 the price dropped to $17.5 million. A contract was pending by July 16, and the sale closed on August 27 at $19 million.
Measured against the $17.5 million price in effect when the bidding started, the sale came in 8.6% over. Against the $19.5 million spring price, it was about 2.6% under. Against the $23 million price from fall 2025, it was about 17% under. It took roughly nine months to go from the first 2025 listing to a contract. All three percentages describe the same house and the same buyer. Bidding over the July 4 weekend came after the June price cut and ended $1.5 million above the reduced price.
None of this takes away from the sale. Larchmont Loop quoted listing agent Linda Filby: "Setting a new record for Larchmont's MLS at $19,000,000 is a strong signal that our market is attracting very serious, well-qualified buyers willing to pay top dollar for the right property here." The previous record, according to lohud's 2021 report, was $11.3 million for 25 Park Avenue, a waterfront house that had last sold for $10.4 million in 2006. The record went up by $7.7 million in five years, and the Hommocks Road house sold for more than two and a half times its 2020 price. Its size depends on the source: the public record lists 9,231 finished square feet, and the listing data gives a larger number.
Elm and Linden went over asking within two weeks
Most of the other higher-end Larchmont sales this year went differently. Five of the seven houses below closed above their first asking price after reaching contract in two weeks or less. One closed at asking and one closed below.
| Address | First asking price | Days to pending | Closed price | Versus first asking price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 6 Linden Avenue | $2,950,000 | 9 | $3,405,000 | about +15% |
| 1 Elm Avenue | $3,195,000 | 7 | $3,612,118 | about +13% |
| 10 Wildwood Road | $2,499,000 | 14 | $2,676,711 | about +7% |
| 12 Linden Avenue | $3,450,000 | 12 | $3,550,000 | about +3% |
| 30 Elm Avenue | $4,795,000 | 11 | $4,825,000 | about +1% |
| 3 Oak Lane | $5,300,000 | 28 | $5,300,000 | at asking |
| 69 Prospect Avenue | $4,997,500 | 17 | $4,485,000 | about −10% |
These listing histories run from April through November 2026.
6 Linden Avenue, built in 1890 with glimpses of Long Island Sound, was listed May 7 and was under contract by May 16. It closed November 3 for $455,000 over its asking price. 1 Elm Avenue went to contract in a week and closed at $3,612,118. That odd final number is the kind that usually comes out of competing offers. 12 Linden Avenue was listed on September 15, after the summer market had ended, and was under contract in 12 days.
69 Prospect Avenue, a Manor house built in 1868 near the beach, didn't follow the pattern. It was listed April 24 at $4,997,500, went to contract May 11 with no recorded price cut, and closed in August at $4,485,000, roughly 10% under. It went to contract quickly, so buyers were interested. The asking price was simply higher than what the buyer and seller eventually agreed on. A list-to-sale percentage can't tell you whether that gap came from the original price or from something found after the contract was signed.
Across these seven sales, the further a first asking price sat from what buyers would pay, the less the closing percentage said about demand. 217 Hommocks Road and 69 Prospect Avenue had the same kind of gap. One seller closed it by cutting the price before a contract. The other closed it in the contract itself.
One $19 million sale and the Larchmont average
Larchmont Loop wrote that the average price of a Larchmont home "is now well over $2 Million." The fall closings support that, and they also show how much one sale can move an average.
Compass's Larchmont sold listings show 31 single-family homes in the 10538 ZIP code that closed between August 19 and November 13, 2026. They range from $980,000 at 132 Laurel Avenue to $5.3 million at 3 Oak Lane, plus the $19 million record. Counting all 31, the average is about $3.2 million and the median is about $2.6 million. Without Hommocks Road, the average falls to about $2.67 million and the median to about $2.47 million. One house moves the average by more than half a million dollars and the median by about $130,000.
The same ZIP code also includes co-op apartments on Palmer Avenue that sold this fall for $195,000 to $241,000, and a unit on Alden Road that sold for $270,000. An average for all of 10538 combines those apartments, Manor houses and a waterfront estate. A buyer looking at three- and four-bedroom houses in Larchmont should look at the middle of the single-family list. This fall that meant 49 Eton Road at $2,050,000, 33 Maple Hill Drive at $2,211,000, 78 Shore Drive at $2,340,000 and 21 Old Colony Drive at $2,600,000.
How the county numbers compare
Westchester County as a whole also sold over asking this year, but less so as the year went on. OneKey MLS reported that single-family homes countywide received 106.2% of original list price in the third quarter of 2026, at a median price of $1,189,000, with 28 days on market and 2.5 months of supply. In October 2026, according to OneKey MLS, the county figure fell to 102.1% of original list price, days on market rose to 42 and 921 homes were in inventory.
Those county figures use the original list price, so a house that sells after a price cut counts against its first number. The Hommocks Road sale was reported as 8.6% over asking, but measured against its spring 2026 list price it closed below. The difference is that the published percentage used the reduced price. Larchmont's Manor sales cost roughly twice the county median, and several of them still went over asking faster than the county average in the third quarter. The extra price wasn't what slowed a listing down. Listings that started above what buyers would pay waited for a price cut, and the bidding came after the cut.
What a listing history tells you before you offer
A buyer who sees "sold 8.6% over asking" or a strong town average this winter should check two things in the listing history before relying on the number. The first is the original asking price and any changes since. The second is how many days the house took to reach a contract. A house that went to contract in nine days at a price close to its neighbors' sales is reliable evidence of current demand. A house that sold over its third asking price after nine months mostly shows that the third price was low enough to draw bids.
Both kinds of sale count as comparables when you set an offer. The Linden Avenue sales show what buyers paid for a Manor house this year when it was priced to bring offers in the first week. The Hommocks Road sale shows that Larchmont's waterfront has buyers at $19 million who were not there at $23 million.
Is $19 million now the benchmark for Larchmont waterfront homes?
It is the top recorded sale for a Larchmont address. The house sold for $7,215,000 in 2020 and was then extensively renovated, so the price reflects that one house as much as its waterfront location.
Are Larchmont homes still going over asking this late in the year?
12 Linden Avenue was listed in mid-September, closed November 3 at about 3% over asking, and 10 Wildwood Road closed November 13 at about 7% over. The countywide figure fell between the third quarter and October, so expect smaller margins over asking this winter, and expect them where the first asking price was close to recent sales nearby.
If you're comparing Larchmont houses this winter and want to see how a particular listing has been priced over time, Jenny Jaffe can go through its full history and the nearby Manor and Town sales with you, so your offer is based on the house's actual record. Schedule a Local Market Consultation, and we'll start from the first asking price.